Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Tampa Car Accident Lawyer
FREE Consultations Available
Tampa Car Accident Lawyers > Blog > Personal Injury > 3M Wins Lawsuit Alleging Defective Earplugs Resulted In Soldier Deafness

3M Wins Lawsuit Alleging Defective Earplugs Resulted In Soldier Deafness


3M recently announced a major victory in a lawsuit that alleged they sold defective earplugs to the U.S. military that resulted in several soldiers losing their hearing. A federal jury, however, sided with the company and found that the company’s earplugs did not cause the soldiers’ deafness.

This is the second of three trials that could determine whether or not over 200,000 U.S. soldiers who lost hearing were sold defective equipment by the company. 3M lost the first trial and was forced to pay $7.1 million to three army veterans who suffered hearing loss and tinnitus. The second trial, which the plaintiff lost, involved one plaintiff who claimed to have suffered hearing loss as a result of the defective earplugs.

236,000 veterans are a part of multi-district lawsuits against the company. The soldiers claim that the company made material misrepresentations about their products. 3M stands by their combat earplugs and insists that they are safe and effective to use. Plaintiffs say that the earplug can become dislodged subtly leaving the wearer without protection. No recall was ever issued, and a new generation of the same earplugs are still in use by the military. However, 3M was forced to pay over $9 million to resolve allegations that they knowingly sold defective equipment to the U.S. military.

Bellwether trials 

Bellwether trials are those that seek to test the waters on specific claims. There are three lawsuits scheduled, two of which are now over. These trials provide both sides with a guesstimate on what the total damages will be, which claims will be honored, and what a final settlement should look like. The loss of the second trial could present future litigants with a hurdle to overcome.

The second trial presented more difficulty than the first because the plaintiffs did not have regular exposure to artillery or helicopters or other machinery that could produce sounds loud enough to destroy someone’s hearing. The plaintiffs focused on 3M’s conduct, the coverup, and the fines levied against the company. However, the plaintiffs failed to directly connect the hearing loss to the failure of the 3M equipment. This, in fact, resulted in the loss of the trial.

Such a trial can set a bar on the criteria for honoring specific claims against 3M in the future. With one win for the defense and another for the plaintiffs, it is likely that jurors are looking for specific proof that the veteran was exposed to loud noises on a regular basis and relied on 3M earplugs to protect their hearing. Nonetheless, soldiers who wore 3M earplugs appear to be suffering symptoms related to the loss of hearing.

It seems there is more similarity than difference between the first set of plaintiffs who won their case with a large jury award and the second set of plaintiffs who received nothing at all. In the first trial, 3M was hit with punitive damages for gross negligence and willful misconduct. In the second trial, 3M was cleared of allegations of negligence. So, two outcomes couldn’t be more different.

Talk to a Tampa Personal Injury Attorney Today 

If you were injured by a dangerous or defective product or a product that did not perform as advertised, the Tampa personal injury attorneys at The Matassini Law Firm can file a claim and help you recover damages related to your injuries. Call today to learn more.



Facebook Twitter LinkedIn

The experience you need in your pursuit of justice

The greatest distinguishing feature among attorneys is their level of experience. Our firm has more than 60 years of legal experience, much of it spent in the courtroom at trial. As a result, our Tampa personal injury lawyers rarely encounter an unfamiliar situation and can thoroughly answer your urgent questions. Our criminal defense practice features a board certified criminal trial lawyer and two former prosecutors with impressive knowledge of trial tactics and procedures.

The resources to provide quality representation for the length of your case

Whether your case involves medical malpractice, an auto accident or a wrongful death, your attorney must be prepared to take the case all the way through trial to verdict. Many personal injury attorneys advance the cost of litigation, so they can only last so long before financial pressures start to mount. As a client, you have to wonder whether an attorney's advice to settle your case reflects the quality of the offer or your attorneys need to get paid. Fortunately, The Matassini Law Firm has the resources to pursue civil verdicts and settlements that reflect the actual value of your case.

Call our Tampa Bay car accident lawyers for a free consultation

A crisis in your life calls for capable and compassionate assistance. The Matassini Law Firm, P.A. addresses your needs all the way through the legal process. For your free initial confidential conference with one of our Tampa car accident attorneys, call us today at 813-217-5715 or contact us online.

Share This Page:
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn
Toll Free
2811 W. Kennedy Blvd., Tampa, Florida 33609