Skip to main content

Exit WCAG Theme

Switch to Non-ADA Website

Accessibility Options

Select Text Sizes

Select Text Color

Website Accessibility Information Close Options
Close Menu
The Matassini Law Firm, P.A. Your trusted legal advisors since 1976

Four People Killed in Three Overnight Bay Area Crashes


Three separate crashes in a 24-hour period claimed four lives and created some complex legal questions for Tampa car accident attorneys to answer.

In the first wreck, Ralph Innamorato was waiting to enter a gas station on Seven Springs Boulevard. He pulled directly into the path of an oncoming motorcycle, ridden by Bradley Casler and Alia Rodger. They were subsequently declared dead at a local hospital, and charges are pending against Innamorato.

Several hours later, Xavier Brown, who was speeding northbound on U.S. Highway 19, smacked into the rear of a dump truck, driven by Brandon Dalinda. Brown sustained fatal injuries at the scene of the wreck.

Several hours later, Corey Shoffner was crossing State Road 589 on foot when Steven Barry fatally struck him.

Failure to Yield Right-of-Way Crashes

Left-turn motorcycle crashes like the one described above constitute about a third of the fatal motorcycle wrecks in Hillsborough County. Some riders employ safety tricks, like wearing brightly-colored clothes or helmets, to improve their visibility. But there is little or no evidence that these tricks are effective. So, the best thing for riders to do is to assume that motorists do not see them, because in many cases, that’s probably true.

FTYROW crashes could involve the negligence per se doctrine. If the tortfeasor (negligent driver) violated a safety law, the tortfeasor could be liable for damages as a matter of law. But Florida’s negligence per se doctrine is complex.

If the tortfeasor broke a non-penal safety law, like failing to yield the right-of-way, negligence per se is a presumption of negligence. The victim/plaintiff must introduce additional evidence to establish liability. But if the tortfeasor broke a criminal safety law, such as DUI with serious injury, no additional evidence is necessary.

These crashes could also involve the last clear chance doctrine, which is discussed below.

Pedestrian-Vehicle Accidents

Speed is one of the leading factors in motor vehicle crash fatalities. Excessive velocity is even more important in vehicle-on-pedestrian claims. If the tortfeasor was travelling slower than 20mph, the pedestrian fatality rate is about 10 percent. The fatality rate catapults to 90 percent at impact speeds of 40mph or greater.

If the victim was not in a marked crosswalk, which is usually the case, insurance company lawyers often bring up the sudden emergency defense. This defense excuses liability if the tortfeasor:

  • Reasonably reacted to
  • A “sudden emergency.”

Most people react reasonably to crashes. They pull over to the side of the road and wait for emergency responders to arrive.

However, the “sudden emergency” prong is different. These words are in quotation marks because not everything constitutes a sudden emergency. This label applies to things like lightning strikes, violent wind gusts, hood fly-ups, and other completely unexpected situations. This label does not apply to jaywalking pedestrians, large potholes, stalled vehicles, and other everyday hazards.

Third Party Liability

Sometimes, the tortfeasor is not the only party responsible for damages. In most crashes involving dump trucks, Uber drivers, taxis, and other commercial vehicles, the respondeat superior rule applies. Employers are liable for the negligent acts their employees commit during the scope of employment. So, in the third crash described above, the dump truck owner, and not Dalinda, might be responsible for damages.

But wait. Didn’t the other driver rear-end the dump truck? Yes, and that’s where the last clear chance rule may come into effect. If Dalinda had a chance to avoid the crash, perhaps by changing lanes, and did not take advantage of that chance, he is legally responsible for the wreck.

Vicarious liability theories like respondeat superior are particularly important in catastrophic injury claims. Many times, individual tortfeasors do not have enough insurance coverage to provide fair compensation in these situations.

Contact Savvy Lawyers

Vehicle collisions often cause serious injuries. For a free consultation with an experienced car accident injury attorney in Tampa, contact The Matassini Law Firm. Home and hospital visits are available.

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn
Skip footer and go back to main navigation